What does justice really look like when you move beyond the courtroom and into the lives of the people forced to carry it out? In this two-part conversation, The Murder Police Podcast sits down with author Daniel Mark Grace to discuss his novel In the Wake of Golgotha and the deeper questions that connect ancient […]
4 Episodes | Starting Tuesday February 17, 2026 A father’s worry, a 14.7-second call, and a grainy tape from a SuperAmerica lot set a true crime story in motion. We walk you through the final hours of 18-year-old reserve officer Myra Stalbosky—her truck trouble on I-65, a rest area encounter with a trucker, and a […]
Tuesday January 20, 2026 A father’s worst fear met a hard truth: remains found near a previously searched area were identified as Little Timmy Sterner. We invited Timmy’s dad, Tim, and stepmom, Ashley, to share what changed, what hasn’t, and how a family holds steady when communication from investigators goes quiet. The conversation moves from […]
Tuesday January 13, 2026 The mics are live again and the purpose is sharper than ever. After months of moving chaos, a dismantled studio, and a nasty bout of cervical nerve pain, we return with a Season 12 recap, a clear-eyed plan for Season 13, and a commitment that guides every decision: we never rush […]
Tuesday August 19, 2025 What drives a mother to murder her own children? The Susan Smith case continues to haunt us nearly three decades later, raising profound questions about evil, justice, and the darkest corners of human nature. When Susan Smith reported that her two young sons had been kidnapped by a Black carjacker in […]
Tuesday July 22, 2025 The suspicious death of John O’Keefe and the subsequent trials of Karen Reed have divided communities, sparked heated debates online, and left countless questions unanswered. Was this a tragic accident, or something far more sinister? Join Wendy and David as they each share “3 Things” that they take away from this […]
Parts 1 and 2 on Tuesday July 15, 2025 Want to learn more about David Lyons’ book True Crime and Consequences? Here you go! Join David on these two episodes as Scott Harvey (author of Silence Kills) interviews David about True Crime and Consequences. You will hear why David wrote this book and what the […]
Tuesday July 8. 2025 Unlocking the secrets of deception through body language and strategic questioning—Eddie Pearson returns for the final installment of our riveting four-part series on reading what’s not being said. Your body betrays your words. Despite our best efforts to control our non-verbal communication, our physiological responses—from subtle changes in breathing to unconscious […]
Tuesday July 1, 2025 The human body betrays what the mind tries to conceal. From ancient Chinese techniques using rice to detect lies to modern statement analysis methods, our conversation with Eddie Pearson reveals the fascinating science behind deception detection. When someone lies, their brain experiences increased cognitive load – the mental strain of fabricating […]
Tuesday June 24, 2025 Eddie Pearson pulls back the curtain on interrogation psychology, revealing that our feet—not our faces—often betray our true feelings. “The feet are the most honest part of the body,” he explains, drawing from decades of experience reading subtle cues that most people miss. Far from the Hollywood portrayal of intimidating interrogators, […]
Tuesday June 17, 2025 Forget everything you’ve seen in crime dramas about slamming tables and bright lights. Former detective Eddie Pearson reveals the subtle science behind real interrogation techniques in this eye-opening conversation about body language and statement analysis. The forehead serves as the “billboard of body language,” where trained investigators can read microexpressions that […]
Tuesday June 10, 2025 A decade of unanswered questions haunts the family of Linda Price, who vanished from a small Kentucky community leaving behind only whispers, theories, and a mother and son determined to bring her home. The truth seems tangled in the complex web of small-town silence. Linda’s son Chase and her mother Mary […]
Tuesday June 3, 2025 The haunting disappearance of Linda Price tears at the heart of a Kentucky family as whispered secrets circulate but answers remain elusive. Mary Elizabeth never imagined she would hear news about her missing daughter from inmates at the Lincoln County Jail where she worked. “Miss Mary, we have family out there. […]
Tuesday May 27, 2025 The haunting disappearance of three-year-old Madeleine McCann from her family’s vacation apartment in Portugal continues to captivate and disturb us nearly two decades later. What began as a parents’ nightmare on May 3, 2007, has evolved into one of the world’s most enduring missing child cases, spawning international investigations, media frenzies, […]
Tuesday May 20, 2025 A mother’s faith doesn’t waver, even after a decade of searching for her missing son. Sandra Hasty and daughter Jennifer share the haunting story of Michael Gorley’s disappearance from rural Kentucky—a case marked by strange encounters, spiritual guidance, and the frustrating knowledge that someone knows exactly what happened. The details paint […]
Tuesday May 13, 2025 A mother’s intuition and a sister’s unexplainable spiritual experience drive the desperate search for Michael Keith Gorley after his Ford Explorer is discovered partially submerged in a pond on Wilderness Trail Road in Lincoln County, Kentucky. Sandra Hasty and Jennifer Gorley Coffey take us through the bewildering days following Michael’s disappearance, […]
Tuesday May 6, 2025 The unsolved disappearance of Michael Keith Gorley haunts the backroads of rural Kentucky like a ghost story without an ending. Ten birthdays, ten Christmas mornings, ten Mother’s Days have passed while his family waits for answers that never come. Sandra Hasty remembers the last morning she saw her son – May […]
Tuesday April 2, 2025 Join Wendy and David for their 3 Things, this time, on Jeffrey Dahmer. The case of Jeffrey Dahmer continues to haunt our collective consciousness decades after his crimes came to light. What makes this story so deeply disturbing isn’t just the shocking nature of his murders, but the stark contrast between […]
Tuesday April 21, 2025 A split jury verdict that defied expectations. Three men dead. A defendant who confessed but later died by suicide in prison. The Lexington Triple Homicide conclusion reveals the devastating consequences when drug culture, family violence, and opportunity collide. The detective’s theory makes disturbing sense – victims who crashed hard after a […]
Tuesday April 15, 2025 When detectives locate Ricky at a Louisville Red Roof Inn following a triple homicide in Lexington, they’re stunned by his immediate confession: “I killed Aaron and Isaac and I’m proud I did it.” But this chilling admission deliberately omits any mention of his stepfather Frank – the third victim discovered at […]
Tuesday April 8, 2025 A routine death call transforms into a detective’s worst nightmare when one body becomes three in a matter of hours. When Frank Reschke is found murdered in his recliner, detectives quickly realize they’re missing two crucial elements – the victim’s car and his stepson, Ricky Sherroan. What follows is a masterclass […]
Tuesday March 18, 2025 A horrifying betrayal lies at the heart of Edwin and Bessie Morris’s murder. The elderly couple was brutally killed in their Kentucky home—not by strangers, but by the son of Edwin’s best friend and his violent accomplices. The nightmare for the Morris family began with a confusing phone call delivering unimaginable […]
Tuesday March 18, 2025 The quiet town of Gray Hawk, Kentucky had one stoplight in the entire county. Nobody locked their doors. Everyone knew everyone. It was here that Edwin and Bessie Morris built their life, running the local grocery store, post office, and gas station. Their grandson Mark Morris remembers them as pillars of […]
“3 Things” with Wendy & David February 11, 2025 Join Wendy and David in this episode of The Murder Police Podcast, where they pilot a new concept called “3 Things”. They analyze the 2024 Netflix documentary Cold Case: JonBenét Ramsey and discuss three major aspects that stood out to them. The case, which remains one […]
With Briana Johnson November 26, 2024 In the latest episode of the Murder Police Podcast, listeners are drawn into the poignant and mysterious story of Little Timmy Sterner, a case that has left a small town searching for answers. This episode, the eighth and final installment of the “Never Forget Little Timmy” series, brings to […]
With Randall Smith November 13, 2023 In our latest episode, we dive deep into the heart-wrenching story of Timmy, a young man whose disappearance has left a community searching for answers. Join us as we sit down with Randall Smith, Timmy’s close friend, who shares his emotional journey and the desperate quest for justice. This […]
With Randall Smith November 12, 2023 Never Forget Little Timmy. In the latest episode of the Murder Police Podcast, we are taken on an emotional journey through the eyes of Randall Smith, a lifelong friend of the missing Little Timmy Sterner. This gripping episode explores the deep bonds of friendship and the chilling mystery surrounding […]
With Cheyenne Brock & Billie Fain October 22, 2024 In the latest episode of the Murder Police Podcast, listeners are drawn into the haunting mystery of Timmy Sterner’s disappearance, a case that has left a community in Nicholasville, Kentucky, searching for answers. This gripping episode features heartfelt interviews with Cheyenne Brock and Billie Fain, two […]
With Sandy Sterner & Terrance Sterner Part 3 | October 8, 2024 Part 4 | October 9, 2024 In the latest episode of our podcast, we delve into the haunting and heart-wrenching story of Timothy Sterner’s disappearance—a case that has left a profound impact on his family and community. This episode is not just about […]
With Tammy Sterner and Sabra VanWinkle September 24, 2024 In this emotionally charged episode of The Murder Police Podcast, we continue to unravel the tragic story of Little Timmy Sterner. We are joined by his sister, Sabra VanWinkle, and his mother, Tammy Sterner, who share poignant memories and shed light on the events leading up […]
With Tim Sterner and Ashley Wethington September 10, 2024 In the latest episode of our true crime podcast, we delve into the deeply emotional and heart-wrenching case of Timmy Sterner. This episode, titled “Never Forget Little Timmy | Part 1,” is the first part of a series dedicated to uncovering the truth behind Timmy’s disappearance. […]
Where we have been and where we are going. September 5, 2024 Season Ten of the Murder Police Podcast: Unraveling Mysteries and Seeking Justice As we bid farewell to Season Nine, the Murder Police Podcast is back with a gripping new season. Season Ten promises to be our most compelling yet, as we dive deep […]
The Unsolved Murder of teenager Letha Rutherford June and July 2024 In the heart of rural Kentucky, a mystery remains unsolved. The disappearance of Letha, a beloved young woman, has haunted her family and community for over three decades. This week’s podcast episode delves into the chilling details of her case, revealing the emotional rollercoaster […]
The Unsolved Murder of teenager Letha Rutherford Tuesday May 8, 2024 The Heartbreaking Tale of Letha Rutherford: A Story of Friendship, Loss, and Unanswered Questions In this week’s episode of the Murder Police Podcast, we delve into the haunting case of Letha Rutherford, a young woman whose life was tragically cut short, leaving behind a […]
A BONUS Episode on The Unsolved Murder of teenager Letha Rutherford Monday May 27, 2024 In the latest episode of the Murder Police Podcast, we dive into the haunting and unresolved case of Letha, a woman whose murder has remained unsolved for over three decades. This episode features an intimate interview with Hannah Hafley, Letha’s […]
The Unsolved Murder of teenager Letha Rutherford Tuesday May 14, 2024 The Murder Police Podcast has once again gripped its listeners with a haunting episode that delves into the cold yet still smoldering case of Letha Rutherford. This week, with Wendy away, David brings us closer to the heart of darkness that is an unsolved […]
Where Is Rhonda? The Mysterious Disappearance of Rhonda Day | Part 1 of 2 4/30/2024Where Is Rhonda? The Mysterious Disappearance of Rhonda Day | Part 2 of 2 5/1/2024 Watch this on YouTube NOW! When the threads of a close-knit family are frayed by the disappearance of one of their own, the void leftbehind is […]
Lou Anna Red Corn Part 1 | The Role of the Commonwealth’s Attorney | April 4, 2024Lou Anna Red Corn Part 2 | Killers of the Flower Moon | April 16, 2024 Join the conversation with Lou Anna Red Corn, whose esteemed career as the retired Fayette County Commonwealth’s Attorney unveils the solemn duty of […]
The Police Polygraph with Detective Eddie Pearson | Part 1 of 2 | March 5, 2024The Police Polygraph with Detective Eddie Pearson | Part 2 of 2 | March 19, 2024 In our latest podcast episode, we delve deep into the world of polygraph examinations, often dubbed as lie detectors, with Detective Eddie Pearson, whose […]
January 23, 2024 Watch this and other cases on YouTube! https://www.youtube.com/c/TheMurderPolicePodcast As the sun sets on 2023, we extend our heartfelt thanks to you, our global family, for joining us on a journey through darkness and light in the realm of true crime. We’ve shared tears and triumphs, recalling the chilling unraveling of Todd Schumacher’s […]
Missing: Kevin “KJax” Jackson | Part 1 of 2 | Tuesday September 19, 2023 Missing: Kevin “KJax” Jackson | Part 2 of 2 | Tuesday September 26, 2023 Watch this and other cases on YouTube! https://www.youtube.com/c/TheMurderPolicePodcast In this episode of the Murder Police Podcast, we delve into the chilling mystery of Kevin “KJax” Jackson’s disappearance. […]
Missing: Kevin “KJax” Jackson | Part 1 of 2 | Tuesday September 19, 2023 Missing: Kevin “KJax” Jackson | Part 2 of 2 | Tuesday September 26, 2023 Watch this and other cases on YouTube! https://www.youtube.com/c/TheMurderPolicePodcast In the world of true crime, there are few stories as heartrending as that of a mother searching for […]
The Murder of Goldia Massey| Part 1 | Tuesday August 8, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 2 | Tuesday August 8, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 3 | Tuesday August 15, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 4 | Tuesday August 22, 2023 The Murder of Goldia […]
The Murder of Goldia Massey| Part 1 | Tuesday August 8, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 2 | Tuesday August 8, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 3 | Tuesday August 15, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 4 | Tuesday August 22, 2023 The Murder of Goldia […]
The Murder of Goldia Massey| Part 1 | Tuesday August 8, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 2 | Tuesday August 8, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 3 | Tuesday August 15, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 4 | Tuesday August 22, 2023 The Murder of Goldia […]
The Murder of Goldia Massey| Part 1 | Tuesday August 8, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 2 | Tuesday August 8, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 3 | Tuesday August 15, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 4 | Tuesday August 22, 2023 The Murder of Goldia […]
The Murder of Goldia Massey| Part 1 | Tuesday August 8, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 2 | Tuesday August 8, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 3 | Tuesday August 15, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 4 | Tuesday August 22, 2023 The Murder of Goldia […]
The Murder of Goldia Massey| Part 1 | Tuesday August 8, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 2 | Tuesday August 8, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 3 | Tuesday August 15, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 4 | Tuesday August 22, 2023 The Murder of Goldia […]
The Murder of Goldia Massey| Part 1 | Tuesday August 8, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 2 | Tuesday August 8, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 3 | Tuesday August 15, 2023 The Murder of Goldia Massey | Part 4 | Tuesday August 22, 2023 The Murder of Goldia […]
The Murder of Charlie Sowers | Part 1 of 3 | Tuesday June 20, 2023 The Murder of Charlie Sowers | Part 1 of 3 | Tuesday July 4, 2023 The Murder of Charlie Sowers | Part 1 of 3 | Tuesday July 18, 2023 Watch this and other cases on YouTube! https://www.youtube.com/c/TheMurderPolicePodcast Get ready […]
